gentle Leader vs. prong collar (pinch collar)

That Mutt is supportive of a range of dog training methods. This is not about “one vs. the other” however instead focuses on a few of the pros & cons of different kinds of collars.

There is no dog training collar that is right for each dog.

I have suggested every type of dog training collar to somebody at some point. Every dog is different, as well as every owner is different. What works for my dog is not necessarily going to work for your dog.

I don’t admire dog fitness instructors who try to push a single tool on everyone.

Every type of dog training collar has its location for the right dog in the right situation. This does not mean it’s right for YOUR dog or my dog.

This publish may contain affiliate links. That Mutt may make money from the business mentioned in this post.

Some of those tools to stop a dog’s pulling include:

Pinch/prong collars
Gentle Leaders
No-pull harness
Martingale collar
Chain slip collars

Most dogs are going to respond well to a strong, fun leader who utilizes positive reinforcement together with moderate “corrections.”

The two collars I want to focus on for this publish are the gentle Leader as well as the pinch (prong) collar. They are extremely different tools however are a few of the most typical tools suggest for strong pullers.

Remember that both tools are just that – training tools. They will not magically stop most dogs from pulling. We still have to put in the work.

*Enjoying this article? get realistic dog training tips emailed when a week. Clique aqui

Gentle Leader vs. pinch collar

The gentle Leader is marketed as a gentle choice to be used over a dog’s muzzle, similar to a equine halter.

The gentle Leader is designed to prevent pulling since if the dog handler controls the dog’s head, he controls the dog.

A pinch (prong) collar is usually constructed out of metal as well as has flat prongs distributed evenly around the collar. It should be used high on the dog’s neck, right under his chin, as well as behind his ears.

When the dog pulls, the owner can provide a slight “correction” by pulling up or to the side. This correction is not designed to cause pain. It is meant to redirect a dog’s attention.

Let me explain what I like as well as don’t like about each of these collars. I hope to disprove a few of the assumptions about each.

In a great deal of ways, these tools work extremely much the exact same even though they look significantly different. Both the gentle Leader as well as the prong collar make pulling somewhat uncomfortable for the dog in order to motivate him to stop pulling.

Gentle Leader for dog training

When I was mentor my mutt Ace to walk well on a leash, I utilized the gentle Leader in some circumstances as well as a pinch collar in others.

With my present dog, a Weimaraner named Remy, I am when once again utilizing both tools.

What I like about the gentle Leader

Reason #1: The gentle Leader assists some dogs stay calm

I utilize a gentle Leader when I want to assist the dog calm down. It’s a great tool to utilize when I want to bring my dog along however may be preoccupied.

However, most dogs do freak out a bit when they very first have something over their muzzle area. So it’s important to slowly desensitize your dog to using a gentle Leader utilizing treats. Don’t just slap it on as well as head out for a walk or he will most likely paw at it the whole time, trying to get it off.

By slowly introducing the gentle Leader over a number of days, you will assist your dog see it as a positive experience.

So, back to being calm …

Once the dog is utilized to the gentle Leader, the tool enables me to relax as well as just enjoy costs time with my dog in hectic situations.

Ace with the gentle Leader

For example, if I’m walking my dog downtown while speaking with a buddy as well as holding a coffee in one hand, the gentle Leader is available in handy. It enables me to “check out” a bit from dog training.

My dog Ace was anxious in the car, as well as the gentle Leader worked to assist him chill out a bit. The material around his muzzle calmed him as well as put him in a less excited state of mind.

As one more example, my foster dog was feeling stressed out at an adoption event we attended. He was barking at me as well as having problem settling down. When I put his gentle Leader on him, he was able to lie down next to me as well as relax.

Reason #2: The gentle Leader stops a dog from making those “choking” sounds

The gentle Leader is likewise a great tool to keep my dog from pulling as well as making those “choking” noises.

Remy is a great example of adog who virtually strangles himself on a regular, nylon collar. He gets so excited, panting, pulling, as well as “choking” that he triggers other dogs to get extremely agitated as well.

When Remy wears a gentle Leader, it eliminates his panting as well as choking noises by about 90 percent. When he’s quiet, other dogs are less likely to react.

Since Remy is still discovering exactly how to ignore other dogs during walks, anything that assists him provide off calmer energy is a great thing.

If Remy is calm as well as peaceful on walks, then walks are much, much more enjoyable! That means he gets to go along on more walks!

*Enjoying this article? get realistic dog training tips emailed when a week. Clique aqui

What I don’t like about the gentle Leader

Reason #1: The gentle Leader can put pressure on a dog’s nose as well as eyes

Any collar can be dangerous if the dog pulls for an prolonged period of time.

The gentle Leader is not always a risk-free tool for extreme pullers.

Are gentle Leaders cruel?

No, they are not cruel. The gentle Leader is marketed as a humane option, as well as for the most part, this is true.

However, when a dog pulls extremely difficult for an prolonged period of time, the thin piece of nylon over his nose begins to put method as well much pressure on the dog’s deal with as well as under his eyes.

Dogs that are so focused on moving ahead do not have sufficient sense to stop pulling, even if they are in pain. The pain may even cause them to pull harder, as they are trying to getaway the pain.

Excited dogs do not always understand exactly how to calm down as well as rationalize what is happening.

Example with my foster dog using the gentle Leader

For example, one time I took foster dog Cosmo for a longer walk than usual. He used his gentle Leader. When we came back, he was squinting his eyes for the rest of the night since of the pressure the gentle Leader had caused.

I was truly worried I had permanently damaged his eyes! I was mad at myself for not stopping during the walk as well as changing to his routine collar.

Thankfully, bug-eyed Cosmo was just fine the next morning. Still, the incident was sufficient for me to re-think the gentle Leader. now I rotate which collar I utilize when I’m walking specific dogs.

For shorter walks, a Gentle Leader may be fine. For longer walks, the pinch collar may be better.

And just for the record, the Halti Head Collar is a similar tool to the gentle Leader, however it’s designed much better as well as generally doesn’t put as well much pressure on a dog’s nose or eyes.

It likewise has a security strap that links to the dog’s typical collar just in situation he slips out of the Halti. For more info, inspect out my publish comparing the Halti vs. gentle Leader.

Reason #2: The gentle Leader does not teach a dog to stop pulling

For many dogs, the gentle Leader is a “Band-Aid” if you are not actively working to really train your dog.

By that, I mean a great deal of dogs discover not to pull as long as they are using the gentle Leader. As soon as you eliminate it, they go right back to pulling.

This is not the end of the world as long as you are okay utilizing the gentle Leader whenever you don’t want your dog to pull. If you want to ultimately wean your dog off the gentle Leader, then try to actively work on “heel” or loose-leash walking.

This is one reason why I utilize the gentle Leader in some circumstances as well as the prong collar in other situations.

My goal is always to get to the point where no training collar is needed at all, as well as I discover it easier to shift from the prong collar to a routine collar since both in shape around the dog’s neck.

Reason #3: Some dogs dislike using a gentle Leader

Most dogs do not have any type of problems with a pinch collar since they’re utilized to having a collar around their neck.. however a great deal of dogs do not like having something over their nose/face area.

My mutt Ace quite much shut down at the sight of his gentle Leader. His tail went between his legs, as well as he looked away. when he had the gentle Leader on as well as we went for a walk, he was fine, however he still avoided me every time I got it out.

My dog Remy likewise runs the other method when he sees me grab the gentle Leader. however if I get the prong collar out, he gets excited as well as comes running!

Like I stated earlier, some dogs truly put up a protest, pawing at their nose as well as scrubing their deal with on the ground in an attempt to get the gentle Leader off.

This is why it’s important to slowly desensitize your dog to using this tool utilizing treats.

Reason #4: You can’t provide a duma correção de coleira enquanto ela está usando um líder gentil

Há circunstâncias em que eu prefiro fornecer a um cão uma “correção” de trela moderada (rebocador no cílio) para fins de treinamento.

O líder suave não foi projetado para correções. De fato, você pode machucar o pescoço deles puxando o líder gentil, embora isso seja improvável.

Cola de beliscão para treinamento de cães (também chamado de colarinho de ponta)

O que eu gosto no colarinho Herm Sprenger Prong

Sugiro a marca Herm Sprenger de colarinho de ponta, pois é a melhor qualidade.

Razão #1: O colarinho de ponta permite fornecer ao cão uma correção suave

Se meu cachorro está focado em um odor ou em mais um cachorro durante uma caminhada, tudo o que ele precisa é um puxão gentil na trela, bem como no colarinho de ponta para re-dirigir sua atenção.

Isso não pretende assustá -lo ou causar dor. É apenas um lembrete para que ele se concentre na tarefa em questão – caminhando. É como um toque no ombro, como, “Oi, lembre -se de mim?”

Normalmente, a resposta do meu cachorro a um desses rebocadores se parece com: “Ha, desculpe. Eu me distraí!”

Eu puxei sua coleira com tanto cuidado que acredito que é realmente o pequeno barulho da movimentação da corrente que chama sua atenção, não a sensação das pontas no pescoço dele. Lembre -se, essas pontas são planas.

Razão #2: A coleira de ponta ajudará a ensinar a um cachorro a não puxar

O colarinho se encaixa em torno do pescoço de um cachorro como um colarinho normal de nylon. Isso simplifica mudar o cão do colarinho para um colarinho de nylon.

Meu cachorro Ace

Quando eu era um mentor craque no calcanhar, eu o faria usar seu colarinho de nylon, bem como seu colarinho de ponta ao mesmo tempo. Esse método eu poderia mudar sua coleira para um colar ou outro conforme apropriado.

Por exemplo, se Ace estivesse andando bem, eu prenderia a coleira dele no colarinho de nylon. Se vissemos mais um cachorro se aproximando, eu prenderia a coleira dele no colarinho.

O que eu não gosto no colarinho

Razão #1: Os links no colarinho de pinça podem se separar

Vi alguns colarinhos se esgotarem, já que uma das pontas estava dobrada. Isso não deve ocorrer se você comprar um colarinho Herm Sprenger Herm Sprenger de alta qualidade.

Eu tive uma marca mais barata por alguns anos e a nossa se separou em uma caminhada quando ou duas vezes. Felizmente, Ace não tinha taxa de juros em fugir. Quando seu colarinho caiu, ele ficou lá olhando para mim. “Bem, você não vai pegar isso?”

Razão #2: O colarinho de pitada é pego em cabelos longos

Eu não gostei do colarinho do meu cachorro adotivo, pois não parecia funcionar com seu pêlo grosso. Ele era um cachorro Eskimo americano.

Funciona muito melhor no meu cachorro Remy, o Weimaraner, que tem pêlo extremamente curto. Eu gostaria de ouvir outras opiniões sobre isso.

Razão #3: O colarinho pode prejudicar um cachorro se não for utilizado corretamente

Um colarinho de ponta é cruel?

O colarinho de ponta não é absolutamente cruel. É uma ferramenta de treinamento humana.

No entanto, não utilizo uma gola de pitada em um cachorro, a menos que esteja calmo. Se estou frustrado com um cachorro, também posso ser atraído para fornecer ao cachorro um puxão mais duro na trela. Não é para isso que serve o colarinho.

Da mesma forma, também vejo muitos donos de cães que não utilizam o colarinho de beliscão como uma ferramenta de treinamento. Eles apenas localizam -o em torno da parte inferior do pescoço de um cachorro e também esperam o melhor.

Mas a gola da pitada foi projetada para ser usada no pescoço do cachorro, logo atrás das orelhas e sob o queixo. Se o colarinho for usado na parte mais grossa do pescoço do cachorro, será tão simples para ela puxar.

O colarinho de pinça deve ser utilizado como uma ferramenta para evitar puxar, não apenas para tornar o puxão mais tolerável para a pessoa.

Razão #4: cães sensíveis podem reagir exageradamente em um colarinho de pitada

Cosmo gritou as primeiras duas vezes em que o corrigi com o colarinho, apesar de ter sido cauteloso por não ser duro. Ele era tão sensível que qualquer tipo de correção o assustou.

Ele também reagiu agressivamente algumas vezes, mordendo a trela. É por isso que algumas pessoas afirmam que um colarinho de ponta pode piorar a agressão de um cão.

Esta não é a situação com a maioria dos cães constantes, no entanto, pode desencadear uma reação de cães sensíveis como o Cosmo. Às vezes, ele reagia em seu colar de nylon de rotina. Eu acredito na sua “birra de temperamento